Thomas Paine was a popular author during the American
Revolution. He was born in England in 1737 to two religious parents (his father
a Quaker and his mother an Anglican). Although Paine grew up in poverty, he was
intelligent, curious, and rebellious through his early years which carried on throughout
his life. Before Paine became a writer he worked many jobs in England, which
included: a corset maker, tobacconist and grocer, schoolteacher, and an
exciseman (639). Eventually, Paine moved to America in 1774 just before the
American Revolution started. He was undoubtedly a strong supporter of
independence from Britain, and this showed in his most successful works “Common
sense” (1775) and “Rights of Man” (1791-92), as well as the first Crisis Paper
(1776), all dealing with his support of independence from Britain and his “plea
against hereditary monarchy” (640). Eventually, Paine ended up in New York in the last years of
his life, writing “The Age of Reason” in 1794, which was written by Paine to
give his personal beliefs on religion.
Thomas
Paine’s main idea in his writing “The Age of Reason” was to that man should
find happiness in his faith in god within himself and not within any form of
organized church. While Paine says that he does not mean to condemn those who
believe otherwise in his beliefs, it is clear that he is very against any
church institutions through his irreverent writing. Paine personally attacks
the Christian church, saying that the church studies the opinions that humans created
about god, rather than god himself and what he has made (656). Paine also
questions the credibility of the bible among other forms of church, saying that
each church’s book has their own form of revelation (or word from god to man)
and this makes any evidence for the existence of god from the church weak. He
explains this, saying “…It is a revelation to that person only. When he tells it
to a second person…and so on, it ceases to be a revelation to all those
persons. It is a revelation to the first person only, and hearsay to every
other, and, consequently, they are not obliged to believe it” (655). Paine also
strongly believed that any form of organized church was “no other than human
inventions set up to terrify and enslave mankind, and monopolize power and
profit” (654), and saw the church and the state as a single corrupt institution.
“The
Age of Reason” caused Thomas Paine to get a lot of backlash from society, and
was ridiculed by its readers and critics. This was because it ultimately argued
that Christianity was human made and not the true source of god’s wisdom,
which offended the majority of Britain, America, and France, as Christianity and
the bible was the most accepted and believed in faith in those countries during
this time period. “The Age of Reason”, however, later paved the way to the Age
of Enlightenment which was a very important intellectual movement that shed
light on scientific thinking.
Works Cited
Paine, Thomas. “The Age of Reason.” Norton Anthology
of American Literature, edited by Nina Baym
and Robert S. Levine, W.W. Norton & Co., 2012, pp. 653-659
I really thought you did an excellent job of explaining Paine’s Age of Reason. I agree that Paine attacked the Christian faith very heavily. I also found that he contradicted what was said earlier, that he does not condemn those who follow the religion, yet he condemns their very religion by saying it “appears to [Paine] a species of atheism; a sort of religious denial of God” (656). To me Paine seems to be reaching out to his audience in the wrong way. He is writing to a devout Christian society, this is not the approach he should have taken. Paine’s writing is far, far ahead of his time.
ReplyDeleteI liked how you got right to the heart of Paine’s Age of Reason, how you knew the central message was pointed to over and over again in the excerpt, that “man should find happiness in his faith in god within himself and not within any form of organized church.” I found that the Age of Reason connects with Jonathan Edwards’ sermon, “Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God.” Both of them point out that the relationship with God should be a personal matter and not through a group.
I think you are a little confused about Paine's text and the Age of Enlightenment. He is writing during the Age of Enlightenment/ Reason, but he doesn't really "pave the way" for it. His writing is in the later period of that movement.
ReplyDeleteMy mistake, for some reason I was under the impression that the age of enlightenment started later but now I know otherwise.Thank you for the correction!
Delete